An owner already has a rental property. They’re considering taking the old house down and building two new ones. The plan sounds straightforward. Sell one when it’s complete and keep the other for income.
When Jason describes this project in Accidental Millionaire, that is what the owner asked him to do. One home was sold and the owner kept the other as a rental. The deal involved two finished buildings and two different jobs for them. One had to release cash. The other had to make sense to hold.
Give each home a job before choosing the design
Picture two houses on the drawing. The home you plan to sell needs a buyer at a supportable price. The home you keep needs a realistic rent, manageable running costs and a debt level you can carry. The home with the highest sale price may also be the strongest rental, so price both allocations.
Ask an agent for comparable sales and rental evidence by dwelling. Number the units on the plan, then compare bedroom count, parking, outdoor space, privacy and access. Each difference should earn its place in the feasibility through evidence or a clearly recorded assumption. If you’re relying on a premium for one of the homes, ask which transactions support it.
Then ask the broker what debt must be repaid when one home settles and what loan remains against the retained one. The solicitor and surveyor should confirm the title structure and sale pathway that the funding assumes. For a Brisbane comparison, council’s subdivision and plan sealing guidance explains the route from completing relevant conditions to lodging a survey plan and registering titles where those steps apply. Brisbane City Council’s subdivision guide · Brisbane City Council’s plan sealing guide
What does the first sale need to leave behind?
In a hypothetical two-home project, you forecast $700,000 from the sale after selling costs. If the lender requires $625,000 to be repaid at settlement and you have $35,000 of other project bills outstanding, that sale leaves $40,000 in cash before any further obligations specific to the project.
Now model the retained home. If it produces $28,000 in annual rent after vacancy and operating expenses and annual debt payments are $24,000, the model shows $4,000 left for the year before any other allowances. A slower leasing period or a higher repayment can reduce it quickly. The cash released from the sale is a different figure from the cash the retained house produces.
What happens if the first home only clears $650,000 after selling costs? The sale is now $10,000 short of the assumed debt repayment and outstanding bills. That result would send you back to the lender and the feasibility before committing to the hold. You might need more cash, a different sale allocation or a sale of both homes.
Jason’s example ended with a sale and a rental. The lesson is to build that exit into the decisions before the project starts, so the property you hope to keep can stand on its own numbers.
WHAT WOULD A TPC STUDENT DO?
- Get separate sale and rental comparisons for each proposed home.
- Ask your broker to confirm the expected debt repayment on the first sale and the borrowing costs on the home you retain.
- Confirm with the solicitor and surveyor when one home can settle on its own, then put that date in the cash-flow forecast.
- Run a lower sale price and delayed rent scenario. Compare the result with selling both homes before choosing the design and exit.
This story draws on Jason Byron’s Accidental Millionaire, pp. 68–69, and the feasibility and development strategies taught in Think Property Club’s Deal Maker course.
Think Property Club illustration of a fictional location.
Sources and boundaries
Sources checked 14 November 2026.
- Brisbane City Council’s subdivision guide — Further reading for this topic.
- Brisbane City Council’s plan sealing guide — Further reading for this topic.
- Deal Maker course — Further reading for this topic.
The locations in the cover artwork are fictional. The technical examples describe an approach to testing a site, a deal or an exit.
The worked examples are for education. Get project-specific advice before relying on a feasibility or agreeing to terms.
Learn with Jason & AmyBuild practical small-scale property development skills with experienced mentors.Enquire nowRate this article
Guest rating: select 1 star for poor or 5 stars for great. No account is required.
Leave a comment
Join the discussion. Your email address will not be published.
Frequently asked questions
What does the home you sell need to achieve?
Its net proceeds need to meet the lender’s required repayment and the project bills that are due.
How do you choose which home to keep?
Get sale and rental evidence for each, then compare debt, cash flow and ownership costs if you swap their roles.
What should be included in the rental forecast?
Start with rent and allow for vacancy, management, rates, insurance and other operating costs, then model debt payments.
When should the team assess separate sale timing?
During feasibility, so the surveyor, solicitor and broker can check whether the programme and title structure support an individual settlement.
What should you test if the sale price falls?
Recalculate the cash available after lender repayment and outstanding costs. Compare funding any gap with changing the exit or selling both homes.

Loading comments…