Think Property Club TV
Think Property Club · Feasibility and conservative numbers · 15 November 2026

Can a cheaper townhouse cost more to live in?

Two sites could fit six townhouses. Compare weekly rent, essential travel and shift-time access to work out which site better serves the renter you want to reach.

Modern Australian townhouses beside a tree-lined footpath and public transport stops.
Price The Rent And The TripTwo townhouse sites and one weekly budget

Six townhouses can look identical on a feasibility sheet. The difference starts when you ask who will live in them and what their week looks like. On pages 128 and 129 of Accidental Millionaire, Jason John Byron describes an unnamed student pursuing six townhouses with an affordable-living aim. The book establishes the proposed product and its purpose. It describes a project under way and gives no completed rental outcome for this account.

Imagine a separate fictional student choosing between two NSW sites for six two-bedroom townhouses. One site is cheaper to build on and the proposed rent is lower. The other has a shorter walk to a service that runs when a prospective renter needs to start work. The student has to decide which site deserves money for concept plans. Comparing advertised rent alone would lead her straight to the cheaper one.

Put the renter’s actual week on the page

Start with one household you can describe. The fictional student models an adult who works a mixture of daytime and early shifts, plus a second household member who needs to reach study and a supermarket. Set the departure and arrival windows before looking up routes. A trip that works at midday can give you the wrong answer for a worker who needs to arrive before dawn. Include the walk to the stop, the transfer, the return trip and a weekend essential trip.

Transport for NSW’s planning tools provide timetables, suggested routes and fare estimates. Use the tool to test representative days at the actual hours, then walk the route and record places where a steep path, poor lighting or a difficult crossing changes how useful the trip is. If someone needs step-free access, ask them to test whether the actual route suits them. An agent’s phrase about being close to transport can become a useful finding once you have checked when and how the service works.

Price the two options on the same week

In this example, Site A is modelled at $495 in rent and $92 for the household’s essential weekly travel. The $92 includes a budget for the part of the early shift journey the modelled service does not cover. That puts the combined weekly cost at $587. Site B is modelled at $530 in rent and $38 in travel, for $568 in total. The fictional renter pays $35 more in rent at Site B and spends $19 less each week across the two budget items.

Keep the travel assumptions visible, especially if they rely on an irregular taxi trip or an existing vehicle. In the example, Site A becomes equal if its travel cost falls to $73 with everything else held constant. A real student would rerun the calculation for a car-owning renter and for a household relying on public transport. Neither worked example represents a posted fare or current rent.

Make the renter result earn a place in feasibility

On the development side, the extra $35 in rent would add at most $210 a week across six fully let homes at the modelled rents. That figure is gross rent before vacancy and operating costs. It does not pay for a higher site cost automatically. Compare verified rents and realistic leasing time, and cost both designs on the same scope. Ask a local property manager for recent, similarly sized and configured townhouses and check what renters actually accepted. NSW Rent Check supplies a postcode rental benchmark based on properties where bonds are lodged. Treat it as one reference point alongside comparable local homes.

In the fictional outcome, the student prices concept work first for Site B. She keeps the higher rent provisional until the property manager finds adequate comparable evidence and the planner checks the assumed six-home outcome. The exercise makes the intended renter’s travel constraints and the developer’s income assumptions visible together. It applies the site and feasibility work in the Think Property Club Deal Maker course to a specific design choice.

WHAT WOULD A TPC STUDENT DO?

  1. Define the intended renter and test essential weekday and weekend journeys at the times they actually travel.
  2. Calculate weekly rent plus travel for each site and find the assumption that would reverse the ranking.
  3. Check recent comparable townhouse rents with a local property manager before carrying a rent premium into feasibility.
  4. Ask the planner to test whether the layout, parking and proposed yield work on the preferred site.

Photographic-style image generated with AI by Think Property Club. The scene is fictional.

Sources and boundaries

Sources checked 15 November 2026.

  1. Transport for NSW - Plan — Provides access to routes, timetables, journey planning and fare estimates.
  2. NSW Government - Rent Check — Explains the postcode rental benchmark drawn from properties with lodged bonds and its limits.

The book verifies the proposed six-townhouse project and its purpose. The two sites, renter profile, transport figures and outcome in the comparison are fictional.

Transport timetables and fares vary. Rent benchmark data is a screening input and offers no project-specific valuation or assurance.

This is development education. The sites, trips and figures are fictional and provide no valuation or assurance about rental affordability, demand or planning approval.

Jason from Think Property ClubLearn with Jason & AmyBuild practical small-scale property development skills with experienced mentors.Enquire now
#Feasibilityandcosts #Sellingandholding #Propertyeducation

Frequently asked questions

Why add travel spending to weekly rent?

It shows whether lower rent leaves more money with the renter once the cost of necessary trips is counted.

What makes the sites equal in the fictional example?

Holding rent and Site B travel costs constant, Site A matches it if weekly travel falls to $73.

Can I use postcode median rent as my feasibility rent?

Use it as a screening input, then check recent comparable townhouses and actual terms with a property manager.

Does good transport access establish that six townhouses can be approved?

Have a planner test the applicable planning controls and have the project team test access, design and services.

How should a household’s car costs enter the comparison?

Choose a consistent basis for both sites and show which costs change with the site. Test alternatives for renters with and without their own car.